Historical clue formulations

• Three-time A.L. M.V.P. of the 2000s, familiarly — 2026-07-23
• Baseball legend who dated J.Lo — 2026-05-24
• Longtime Yankee nickname — 2026-04-15
• Ex-Yankee with appearances on "Shark Tank," familiarly — 2026-04-09
• Yankees nickname until 2016 — 2026-02-22
• Longtime teammate of Derek Jeter, familiarly — 2026-02-13
• Onetime nickname on the Yankees — 2025-09-23
• Yankees nickname from 2004 to '16 — 2024-09-23
• Slugger who ended his career four shy of the 700 home run club — 2024-02-13
• Former Yankee nickname — 2024-02-01
• 14-time M.L.B. All-Star, to fans — 2023-06-06
• M.L.B. player with over 600 career home runs, to fans — 2023-03-12
• M.L.B. all-time leader in grand slams (25), informally — 2022-07-29
• Nickname in baseball and gossip columns — 2022-02-13
• J.Lo's onetime beau — 2021-12-08
• Former-Yankee-turned-broadcaster, to fans — 2021-11-19
• Baseball great who was once engaged to J.Lo — 2021-07-06
• Sports star who split with J.Lo in 2021 — 2021-06-17
• Three-time A.L. M.V.P. (2003, 2005 and 2007), informally — 2021-03-01
• Youngest M.L.B. player to hit 500 homers — 2020-09-16
• Newsmaking ex-Yankee, informally — 2020-07-14
• Major-league All-Star turned TV analyst, informally — 2020-02-29
• Yankee nickname until 2016 — 2019-12-10
• Nickname for an ESPN baseball commentator — 2019-10-20
• Half of a celebrity couple with J.Lo starting in 2017 — 2019-07-03
• Former Yankee slugger, familiarly — 2019-03-11
• Longtime Yankee teammate of Sandman — 2019-01-25
• Former Yankee nickname — 2018-11-11
• Star Yankees 3B for 10 seasons — 2018-10-02
• Former Yank with 25 career grand slams — 2018-08-07
• 14-time M.L.B. All-Star, to fans — 2018-02-13
• Bygone Yankee nickname — 2018-01-03
• Onetime Yankee nickname — 2017-09-03
• Longtime Yankee nickname — 2016-12-21
• Yank with 25 grand slams — 2016-07-16
• Yankee nickname beginning in 2004 — 2016-04-20
• Youngest player ever to hit 500 home runs, familiarly — 2016-01-12
• Yankee slugger with the most M.L.B. career grand slams, informally — 2015-09-14
• Member of the 3,000-hit club, informally — 2015-08-09
• Biogenesis scandal figure of '13 — 2015-02-13
• Longtime Yankee nickname — 2015-01-25
• Yankees teammate of Captain Clutch — 2014-12-07
• Biogenesis scandal nickname — 2013-10-16
• Youngest 600-homer man, informally — 2013-08-14
• Longtime teammate of Mr. November — 2013-05-25
• Longtime Yankee nickname — 2013-05-19
• Youngest 600-homer man, informally — 2013-04-17
• Nickname of a three-time A.L. M.V.P. — 2013-04-08
• Yankees' #13, to fans — 2012-06-06
• Hot corner Yank — 2012-05-24