Historical clue formulations

• St. ___ (Caribbean getaway) — 2018-11-21
• St. ___ (Caribbean hot spot) — 2010-07-27
• St. ___ (Caribbean hot spot) — 2009-07-25
• St. ___ (Caribbean island, familiarly) — 2008-01-05
• St. ___ (New York church, informally) — 2002-04-16