Historical clue formulations

• Contrite answer to "Who put the empty ice cream carton back in the freezer?" — 2025-09-17
• "Look what ___!" — 2025-05-22
• Sheepish answer to "Who broke this?" — 2022-12-21
• "Why haven't you …?" retort — 2022-08-20
• "That ___ love thee, Caesar, O, 'tis true": Shak. — 2022-04-02
• Terse confession — 2021-11-07
• Possible response to "Who took the last cookie?" — 2021-09-17
• Brief confession — 2021-04-23
• Terse admission — 2020-02-26
• Terse response accepting responsibility — 2019-08-09
• Terse admission — 2019-01-31
• Brief admission of responsibility — 2016-04-12
• Terse admission — 2014-02-28
• Reply of confirmation — 2013-01-09
• "___ it!" — 2012-05-26
• "___ it my way" — 2012-02-01
• "Look what ___!" — 2011-09-18
• "Look what ___!" — 2010-03-14
• "What ___ for Love" ("A Chorus Line" song) — 2009-06-02
• "Look what ___!" — 2008-12-23
• "Look what ___!" — 2007-03-22
• "What ___ for Love" ("A Chorus Line" song) — 2006-07-29
• "____ it my way" (Sinatra lyric) — 1995-11-13