Historical clue formulations

• "Where did ___ my keys?" — 2020-05-15
• "Hmm, how shall ___ this?" — 2017-05-17
• "___ a Spell on You" (1956 hit) — 2013-08-29
• "___ a Spell on You" — 2012-05-01
• "___ a Spell on You" (classic 1956 Screamin' Jay Hawkins song) — 2009-07-19