Historical clue formulations

• Mascara coats one — 2026-04-20
• A wish might be made on a loose one — 2025-03-18
• Mascara target — 2024-11-25
• The average person will shed at least one every day — 2024-08-23
• Bind with rope — 2024-05-15
• Whip — 2023-11-13
• Verbally lose it, with "out" — 2023-09-30
• Makeup target — 2021-08-15
• Curling target — 2021-03-06
• Bind with rope — 2021-02-07
• Mascara target — 2020-10-27
• The eyes have it — 2019-12-29
• Place for mascara — 2019-05-06
• Where mascara goes — 2019-04-29
• Lid attachment — 2019-01-16
• Cat-o'-nine-tails component — 2018-07-24
• Unit of corporal punishment — 2018-03-20
• Eye protector — 2017-03-23
• Tie securely — 2016-03-05
• Tie securely — 2016-01-01
• Respond angrily, with "out" — 2015-08-04
• Eye liner? — 2014-11-01
• Whip tip — 2014-08-24
• Mascara target — 2014-05-12
• Metaphor for punishment — 2014-02-19
• Stinging rebuke — 2012-12-16
• Shipboard punishment — 2012-10-24
• Old naval punishment — 2012-06-03
• Whip — 2012-03-20
• It might be batted at a knockout — 2012-01-29
• Mascara coats it — 2012-01-02
• Pirate's punishment — 2011-11-03
• Pirate's punishment — 2011-03-23
• Any tail in a cat-o'-nine-tails — 2010-07-18
• Mascara's place — 2008-12-02
• Lid attachment — 2008-10-05
• Secure, in a way — 2008-01-18
• Corporal punishment unit — 2008-01-16
• Whip — 2008-01-15
• Liner's locale — 2007-09-15
• Unit of punishment — 2007-09-06
• Unit of punishment at sea — 2007-08-02
• Make secure — 2007-04-18
• Lid growth — 2006-06-21
• Respond angrily, with "out" — 2004-12-30
• Sailor's punishment — 2004-08-21
• Eyelid attachment — 2003-08-11
• Whip — 2003-07-29
• Lid attachment — 2003-04-03
• Mascara site — 2003-01-14