Historical clue formulations

• Got exactly — 2023-05-23
• Did perfectly — 2013-01-29
• Caught red-handed — 2009-03-08
• Caught but good — 2004-02-22
• Caught in the act — 2003-04-21
• Busted but good — 1999-10-29
• Threw out, as a runner — 1997-09-02
• Caught but good — 1996-12-24
• Hit dead-center — 1995-07-07