Historical clue formulations

• Eggy quaff — 2026-08-16
• Yuletide beverage — 2025-09-30
• Nutmeg-flavored quaff, informally — 2025-09-19
• Holiday party pour — 2025-07-29
• Yuletide drink — 2025-04-15
• Seasonal quaff — 2024-09-29
• Fireside drink, perhaps — 2024-05-04
• Quaff for a caroler, maybe — 2023-08-09
• Holiday quaff — 2023-07-12
• Often-spiked holiday beverage, familiarly — 2023-06-26
• December drink — 2023-04-27
• Drink that can be spiced … or spiked — 2022-08-20
• Christmastime concoction — 2022-04-19
• Drink garnished with nutmeg — 2021-07-18
• Spiced quaff — 2021-04-10
• Seasonal milkshake flavor, informally — 2020-08-08
• Yule quaff — 2020-07-22
• Eggy drink — 2020-06-16
• Creamy beverage — 2019-09-08
• Yule drink — 2019-04-10
• Holiday quaff — 2018-06-12
• Drink often served chilled — 2018-06-02
• Holiday quaff — 2018-04-25
• Christmas bowlful — 2018-03-17
• Holiday drink — 2018-01-22
• It may be spiked in winter — 2016-08-27
• Yule beverage — 2016-07-05
• Drink often served chilled — 2016-03-04
• Nutmeg-topped drink — 2016-02-23
• Yule quaff — 2016-02-02
• Seasonal quaff — 2015-09-05
• Drink with spices — 2015-08-16
• Drink often served with a ladle — 2015-05-19
• Periodic dairy aisle offering — 2014-04-12
• See 54-Across — 2014-02-11
• Seasonal beverage — 2013-11-17
• Yule libation — 2013-10-29
• Creamy concoction — 2013-06-26
• Drink that's stirred — 2013-06-16
• Eggy drink — 2012-09-18
• Eggy Christmas drink — 2012-07-30
• Holiday quaff — 2012-05-20
• Seasonal potation — 2012-04-08
• Holiday quaff — 2011-12-13
• Yule quaff — 2011-05-26
• Seasonal quaff — 2010-06-16
• Drink from a bowl — 2010-04-11
• Eggy drink — 2010-03-30
• Eggy quaff — 2010-03-28
• Yuletide quaff — 2009-06-09